3 minute read

When it comes to hosting static websites, two popular options are GitHub Pages and Cloudflare Pages. Both offer unique features, but which one is right for your project? In this guide, we’ll break down the differences between GitHub Pages and Cloudflare Pages to help you decide.

1. Performance

GitHub Pages

  • Hosted by GitHub with a focus on static site hosting.
  • Sites are served over a CDN, but the performance and caching options are limited compared to some other platforms.
  • Suitable for personal or project documentation sites, simple blogs, and Jekyll-powered sites.

Cloudflare Pages

  • Hosted by Cloudflare, leveraging Cloudflare’s global network for edge hosting, which can result in faster load times due to caching at edge locations close to users.
  • Provides additional performance enhancements like Cloudflare’s DDoS protection and analytics.
  • Ideal for sites that require fast performance and global distribution.

2. Build System and Integrations

GitHub Pages

  • Supports Jekyll out of the box, making it easy to deploy static sites with Jekyll.
  • Limited native build pipeline (just Jekyll) unless you use GitHub Actions to customize the build process (you could use Actions to integrate other static site generators like Hugo or Gatsby).
  • You need to manage custom build processes manually with GitHub Actions or other CI/CD tools.

Cloudflare Pages

  • Has a built-in CI/CD pipeline, supporting several static site generators (Gatsby, Hugo, Next.js, etc.) right out of the box.
  • You can easily integrate with GitHub or GitLab for automatic builds and deployments on push.
  • Automatic deployments with preview URLs for each pull request, which can be useful for collaboration.

3. Custom Domains and SSL

GitHub Pages

  • Supports custom domains with automatic SSL (via Let’s Encrypt) for free.
  • DNS configuration needs to be done manually, and it may not be as intuitive for non-technical users.

Cloudflare Pages

  • Also supports custom domains with free SSL certificates provided by Cloudflare.
  • Much smoother DNS management if you’re using Cloudflare DNS, with automatic integration.
  • Additional security and SSL options (e.g., more control over settings like SSL/TLS versions) are easier to manage via the Cloudflare dashboard.

4. Security

GitHub Pages

  • Provides basic security features, including HTTPS.
  • Limited to GitHub’s platform security and CDN.

Cloudflare Pages

  • Leveraging Cloudflare’s security tools (like DDoS protection, firewall rules, etc.) offers a more robust security setup.
  • Enhanced features like rate limiting, firewall rules, and even WAF (Web Application Firewall) can be easily integrated if needed.

5. Pricing

GitHub Pages

  • Free for public repositories.
  • For private repositories, you need to subscribe to a paid plan (starting from $4/month per user with GitHub Pro or Team plans).

Cloudflare Pages

  • Offers a free tier with up to 500 builds per month.
  • Paid plans are available if you need more builds or advanced features, starting from $20/month.

6. Deployment Flexibility

GitHub Pages

  • Limited to deploying from a branch in your GitHub repository (usually main or gh-pages).
  • Advanced deployment options require additional configuration with GitHub Actions.

Cloudflare Pages

  • More flexible with the built-in CI/CD pipeline.
  • Can deploy from any branch or use other Git repositories (GitLab, Bitbucket, etc.).
  • Better suited for more complex deployment workflows with preview URLs and staging environments.

7. Analytics

GitHub Pages

  • GitHub itself does not provide built-in analytics, so you would need to integrate external tools like Google Analytics.

Cloudflare Pages

  • Cloudflare offers built-in analytics, providing insights into traffic, performance, and security without needing third-party tools.
  • If you’re using Cloudflare’s free plan, some data might be limited, but you can upgrade for more detailed reporting.

8. Use Cases

GitHub Pages

  • Ideal for simple, static websites, documentation, personal blogs, or sites that do not require heavy performance optimization.
  • Better suited for developers already using GitHub for version control and CI/CD.

Cloudflare Pages

  • Suitable for more performance-intensive or globally distributed sites.
  • Ideal for developers who want fast, flexible builds and deployments with minimal setup.
  • Great for those using modern frameworks like React, Next.js, or those who need high-performance static hosting.

9. Conclusion

  • Choose GitHub Pages if you are already deeply integrated with GitHub, want a simple and free solution, and do not need advanced build or deployment features.
  • Choose Cloudflare Pages if you are focused on performance, scalability, and security, or if you are using modern static site generators and need a more flexible deployment pipeline.

You may also enjoy

Getting Started with GitHub Actions for CI/CD

4 minute read

GitHub Actions is a powerful CI/CD (Continuous Integration/Continuous Delivery) tool that allows you to automate workflows directly within your GitHub reposi...